Countryside Insurance Agents

Countryside Insurance has served the residents and businesses of Southern Indiana and Louisville area since 1976.

Susan M. Wathen - President & Account Executive

Phone 812.945.9123
Text Susan 812.207.5278

Susan is the Agency Owner / President and a Life, Personal Lines producer that has been licensed with the agency since 1988. Susan's father started the agency in 1976. She began filing and answering phones during her summer breaks when she was only 12 years old. Susan has coached the Lanesville Jr. High Cheerleaders for several years and loves it! #BPN! In addition, she has volunteered her time with Tri Kappa, the advisory board of Phi Sigma Sigma Sorority at I.U.S., The Boys & Girls Club of Harrison County, Big Brothers/Big Sisters and the Lanesville Protestant Cemetery Board of Directors. Susan is married to Phillip Johnston, a step mother to two sons and a daughter-in-law (Zach, Jesse  & Haley) and the Grandmother of one (Carter).   When she isn't working, coaching or volunteering, Susan loves spending time with her friends & family going to concerts, movies and plays. 


Marilyn J. Curry - Vice President & Account Executive

Marilyn is an Agency Partner / Vice President. She writes life, personal and commercial insurance and has been with the agency since 1979 when she started as a secretary/bookkeeper. She has been married to her high school sweetheart (Ken Curry) for 45 years, has two daughters, four grandchildren and a cute Yorkshire Terrier (Gracie). Marilyn is an active member of Georgetown Christian Church and she and her husband host a home life group. She is also part of the Emmaus Community, where she volunteers her time regularly. Marilyn loves spending time with her family/friends, sewing, baking, and sitting on the back porch with her husband. 

Peggy (Fraley) Pierce - Account Executive

Peggy is a Personal / Commercial Lines producer that has been with the agency since 2010. Outside of work, she keeps busy with being a wife, mom to 6 children, a step-son and numerous pets!  Peggy has a daughter that was diagnosed with a genetic disorder and epilepsy. She spends what free time she has researching treatment options for her daughter. Peggy's weekends are usually spent with her family. When she can, she tries to squeeze in a dinner with friends or a workout at the gym.


Alyssa Kilcoyne  - Commercial Lines & Life Insurance Representative

Alyssa is our Commercial Insurance & Life Insurance Representative. Alyssa will be happy to help you with quotes, changes, payments, claims, Certificates of Insurance, etc. 

Alyssa is originally from Wisconsin. She is a 2015 graduate of University of Wisconsin-Platteville with a degree in AgriBusiness and an emphasis in management. When she isn’t working, she spends her free time training her beagles for hunting competitions and spending time with her friends and family.


Victoria Southard - Personal Lines Representative

Victoria is our Personal Lines Client Representative. Victoria will be happy to help you with quotes, changes, payments, claims, etc.

Victoria is married to Devin Southard, mother to a beautiful daughter (Adeline May) and two fur babies (Bella & Bandit).  In her downtime, she likes to relax by getting her nails done and spending time with her family and friends.  She also tries to enjoy a nightly jog… when the weather cooperates. When it comes to favorite sports teams, her house is divided.  She’s a lifetime Louisville Cardinal fan (#L1C4).  But her husband has brought out her crimson & cream.  She’s now a fan of the Indiana Hoosiers!  Except when they play each other, then it’s Louisville all the way.


Countryside Insurance is an Independent Insurance Agency representing these fine companies.